It started with a jar of eyeballs.*
We prepared the pinata while C lassoed H.
Pinata.
Fake mustaches from the pinata.
* The story behind this: for Christmas Eve, we played our gag gifts game, and one of the gifts was a small glass jar filled with plastic googly eyes. At the end of the game, people were allowed to trade for what they wanted, and Bella traded for the jar of eyeballs. Roz wanted to make her a big one to go with the small one.